Very soon it will be April 1st, a popular day for jokes and tricks. In that spirit, today you will learn about the most misused Social Security number (SSN) of all time. However, unlike an April Fool’s Day trick, this story is true and has its start in the early days of the Social Security program.
This story starts in 1938. To set the stage, remember that having a Social Security number (SSN) was still a relatively new idea. The original Social Security Act of 1935 authorized the creation of a record keeping system but did not expressly mention Social Security numbers.
A 1936 Treasury regulation required the issuance of an account number to each employee covered by the Social Security program. The Social Security Board considered various numbering systems, eventually settling on an early version of Social Security number card so that employees could record their SSN and show it to employers when needed.
Approximately 30 million applications for SSNs were processed between November 1936 and June 30, 1937. Since the Social Security Board did not have a network of field offices in late 1936, it contracted with the U.S. Postal Service to distribute and assign the first batch of Social Security numbers through its 45,000 local post offices around the country.
As part of a product promotion, in 1938 a New York state wallet manufacturer decided to show how well the new Social Security cards fit into its wallets. A sample SSN card was inserted in each wallet for display purposes, much as wallets today often have stock photos in them. Note: today SSA advises people not to carry Social Security number cards with them unless expecting to need it immediately.
This sample card was only half the size of a real card, was printed all in red, and had the word “specimen” written across the face. Unfortunately, it also showed a real Social Security number, that of Mrs. Hilda Whitcher, secretary to the president of the wallet manufacturer.
Woolworth stores and other department stores all over the country sold the wallet. Despite the different size, color and word “specimen” written on the wallet card, many purchasers of the wallet adopted the sample SSN as their own.
How many? A lot. In the peak year of 1943, 5,755 people were using Mrs. Whitcher’s SSN. She was given a new number and the original number voided. To curtail its use, a Social Security campaign publicized that the number was not to be used.
While this might have helped, it did not solve the problem and the SSN “issued by Woolworth” continued to be used for many years. As late as 1977, twelve people still used the SSN. In all, over 40,000 people reported Mrs. Whitcher ‘s original number as their SSN.
What did Mrs. Whitcher have to say about all this? In later years she observed: “They started using the number. They thought it was their own. I can’t understand how people can be so stupid. I can’t understand that.”
Over time there have been over a dozen similar situations but the Whitcher case is by far the worst involving a real SSN and an actual person.
This story is true. Following is a photo of Mrs. Whitcher with her own SSN card and a wallet version.
